How to choose the right web agency for your project

Choosing a web agency is an important decision. The right partner can transform your digital presence and drive business results, while the wrong partner can cost you time, money and nerves. In this article we go through what to think about to make the right choice.

Start with your needs, not with the agency

Before you even start looking for an agency, be clear about what you actually need. Are you building a completely new website? Redesigning an existing one? Developing an app? Or perhaps you need ongoing UX/UI support? The clearer you are about your needs, the easier it is to find an agency that matches.

Also think about what kind of relationship you want. Some companies want an agency that runs the whole project from start to finish, while others prefer to bring in individual specialists who join their own team.

Seven things to check when comparing agencies

1. Portfolio and client cases

An agency's portfolio says more than a thousand sales presentations. Look at the types of projects they have delivered. Do they have experience of assignments similar to yours? Does their design style match what you're after?

2. Technical expertise

Check that the agency has expertise in the technologies you need. If you want to build a modern headless CMS solution, you need an agency with experience of, for example, Next.js, Prismic or similar.

3. Process and communication

How does the agency work? Do they use agile methods? How often do you get status updates? A good agency is transparent about its process and keeps you involved throughout the project.

4. UX and design focus

A good-looking website isn't enough: it also has to be user-friendly and optimised for conversion. Make sure the agency has dedicated UX/UI designers and not just developers who "can also do design".

5. Pricing and transparency

Ask for a clear quote and be sceptical of agencies that can't give you a rough cost estimate. Fixed price, time and materials or a hybrid? The most important thing is that you understand what you're paying for.

6. References and reviews

Ask for references and talk to previous clients. Did the agency deliver on time? Did they stay on budget? Were they easy to work with?

7. Relationship and chemistry

Don't underestimate gut feeling. A web project is a collaboration that can go on for months. You need to trust the people you work with.

Large agency or small agency?

Large agencies can offer breadth and often have established processes, but the price is higher and you risk becoming a small fish in a big pond. Smaller agencies are often more committed and flexible, and give you closer contact with the people who actually do the work.

The best of both worlds is a mid-sized agency with specialist expertise. Big enough to have every role covered, but small enough that every client feels prioritised.

Red flags to watch out for

Be on your guard if the agency doesn't ask about your business goals, can't show a relevant portfolio, promises unrealistic timelines, avoids talking about budget, or if you feel you're being persuaded rather than understood.

Summary: your checklist

Define your needs and goals before you contact agencies. Compare at least three agencies based on portfolio, expertise and references. Prioritise agencies with clear UX expertise. Choose a partner where the chemistry is right and communication flows. And don't forget: the cheapest is rarely the best.

What we do in this area

Want help with this?

Tell us what you want to build and get a quote right away.

Common questions about choosing a web agency

Question not covered here? Call or email us and we'll help.

More articles

We use cookies

We want to measure how the site is used and show relevant ads. We only do that if you agree. Read our cookie policy.